Enjoy the free Classified Ads! 24HourForums.com Home Thank you for supporting us. Click to enter Posts Of The Day.
Recent Posts Search by username
Search Contact Us Login Register
When logged in, click this to open up the Jumper for easier navigation. Click for details on our forum system in the Forum Center.
Click to be shown the (Top 10 and Management) forums listed in the top section of the site. Click to be shown the (Supported) forums listed in the middle section of the site. Click to be shown the (UnSupported) forums listed in the bottom section of the site. Click to learn about, or pay for, forum Sponsorships. Click for the Official Forum Voting Poll. VOTE! Click for info on owning a forum here at 24.

24HourForums.com > The Top 10 Supported Forums > LC's Crimes & Trials > Would you support court-ordered drug "interrogations" of suspects?

Share this topic...
Digg!  - Digg   Slashdot  - SlashDot    - del.icio.us    - Reddit    - StumbleUpon   - Facebook

 Moderated by: Lady Cop Page:    1  2  Next Page Last Page  

New Topic
Reply
Print
Poll
Would you support court-ordered drug "interrogations" of suspects?
   
   
View Results
 

Vote
AuthorPost
sirlamre
Pioneer100© Member
 
Official Forum Troublemaker
Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 5196
MyResume: 
MyJob: Cisco VOIP and network security engineer
MyForum: Political Forum, Religion Forum
MyLove: My wife and Joshua and Daniel!
MyWish: 
MyFile: 
MyIntro: 
MySex: 2 kids - at least twice!
Status:  Offline
MyPOTD: 
Return to topBottom of page
 Posted: 06:49 pm

Quote
Reply
PM
Alert
voters: 0      
Would you support court-ordered drug "interrogations" of suspects, using something like sodium pentothal, or hypnosis, or some other means that isn't torture, but removes a suspects desire to hide the truth?
Something with no permanent effects, no marks, etc.

I'm thinking along the lines of something that would require a lot of review and very compelling evidence of probable cause beforehand (probably far exceeding the standard required for say, a search warrant)

Could require the signatures of two judges, etc --

Ads appear if not logged in.

Lady Cop
Pioneer100© Member


Joined: 
Location: Cape Cod
Posts: 9846
MyResume: [Download]
MyJob:  deputy sheriff (retired)
MyForum: LC's crimes and trials
MyLove: my family
MyWish: 
MyFile: [Download]
MyIntro: [Download]
MySex: straight woman
Status:  Offline
MyPOTD: 
Return to topBottom of page
 Posted: 06:52 pm

Quote
Reply
PM
Alert
voters: 0      
i voted no, it's too invasive. even the polygraph is an investigative tool, and cannot be forced on anyone. i'd rather rely on good old-fashioned gathering of evidence.

:) ::spy:: ::ladycop::
Brian
Grand Poobah of Moderation


Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 4080
MyResume: 
MyJob: 
MyForum: 
MyLove: 
MyWish: 
MyFile: 
MyIntro: 
MySex: 
Status:  Offline
MyPOTD: 
Return to topBottom of page
 Posted: 06:57 pm

Quote
Reply
PM
Alert
voters: 0      
I voted no.  People under the influence of sodium pentathol, hypnosis, etc., are too vulnerable to suggestion.  It's not a way to get accurate information.  If coercive tactics are used to get information, those tactics should at least get reasonably accurate results.  For that, you need the person to be fully conscious and thinking.  You're better off (from an information extraction standpoint) applying pain and then verifying the information than you are to drug somebody up to loosen their tongue.

NB:  I'm not saying I'm in favor of "torture" (depending on how you define the word).  But stressing someone into giving you information is a more reliable way of getting it than trying to get through the back door.




"It's been a long December, and there's reason to believe maybe this year will be better than the last."

-- "A Long December", Counting Crows
foxglovepress
Forum-Blogger©
Original500© Member

NON-PC!!
Joined: 
Location: USA
Posts: 7764
MyResume: 
MyJob: Love my FAMILY, COUNTRY and Dogs!!
MyForum: Politics- Religion- Open Tal
MyLove: Family and ?
MyWish: A government for WE THE PEOPLE!
MyFile: [Download]
MyIntro: [Download]
MySex: On Hold for now.....
Status:  Offline
MyPOTD: 
Return to topBottom of page
 Posted: 07:03 pm

Quote
Reply
PM
Alert
voters: 0      
NO!  With our government and legal system, it would get out of hand and start being abused within the first month or so!  Laws being passed ALWAYS have a ton of loop holes that aren't privy to the public who may be voting on these laws.............Now where I WOULD approve, might be if an innocent person could request it, and be allowed to use this method to help prove innocence!




Justice for Mark.....Imprison Employers Who Hire ILLEGALS!
Lady Cop
Pioneer100© Member


Joined: 
Location: Cape Cod
Posts: 9846
MyResume: [Download]
MyJob:  deputy sheriff (retired)
MyForum: LC's crimes and trials
MyLove: my family
MyWish: 
MyFile: [Download]
MyIntro: [Download]
MySex: straight woman
Status:  Offline
MyPOTD: 
Return to topBottom of page
 Posted: 08:37 pm

Quote
Reply
PM
Alert
voters: 0      
aside from all the considerations mentioned, think of the constitutional nightmare! we can't even inject those lawfully sentenced to death. it might 'hurt'.





sirlamre
Pioneer100© Member
 
Official Forum Troublemaker
Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 5196
MyResume: 
MyJob: Cisco VOIP and network security engineer
MyForum: Political Forum, Religion Forum
MyLove: My wife and Joshua and Daniel!
MyWish: 
MyFile: 
MyIntro: 
MySex: 2 kids - at least twice!
Status:  Offline
MyPOTD: 
Return to topBottom of page
 Posted: 10:41 pm

Quote
Reply
PM
Alert
voters: 0      
whimper....

so I'm guessing this means ya'll won't want to vote for me for President or anything?

::sgrin::


And actually I agree-

Both with Brian and FGP --

Not only is it currently not accurate enough, but it's also one more thing that'd get abused.

It just would be nice if we had a super reliable Constitutional way to find out if some particular person did something or not and GET IT OVER WITH, and have more open and shut cases and trials.

These cases where the guy, the cops, and everyone KNOWS that he did it--- yet he can 'not incriminate himself', and  both legal precedent and his defense lawyer   using every trick in the book combine to make the guy all but unprosecutable..

And cases go on for months and years, costing the taxpayer millions of dollars.....
all because some scumbag and lawyer who KNOW that he did it, and know the system inside and out, work things such that he might get away with it.

If you did the crime, you should do the max time as anyone who was caught redhanded.
Not these crazy cases that the whackjob ends up geting 1/8th the time someone else did for the SAME crime, because he and his lawyer managed to make it SO hard for the cops and the courts to prove and try him for it.

Last edited on 10:47 pm by sirlamre
foxglovepress
Forum-Blogger©
Original500© Member

NON-PC!!
Joined: 
Location: USA
Posts: 7764
MyResume: 
MyJob: Love my FAMILY, COUNTRY and Dogs!!
MyForum: Politics- Religion- Open Tal
MyLove: Family and ?
MyWish: A government for WE THE PEOPLE!
MyFile: [Download]
MyIntro: [Download]
MySex: On Hold for now.....
Status:  Offline
MyPOTD: 
Return to topBottom of page
 Posted: 10:50 pm

Quote
Reply
PM
Alert
voters: 0      
sirlamre wrote: whimper....

so I'm guessing this means ya'll won't want to vote for me for President or anything?

::sgrin::


And actually I agree-

Both with Brian and FGP --

Not only is it currently not accurate enough, but it's also one more thing that'd get abused.

It just would be nice if we had a super reliable Constitutional way to find out if some particular person did something or not and GET IT OVER WITH, and have more open and shut cases and trials.

These cases where the guy, the cops, and everyone KNOWS that he did it--- yet he can 'not incriminate himself', and  both legal precedent and his defense lawyer   using every trick in the book combine to make the guy all but unprosecutable..

And cases go on for months and years, costing the taxpayer millions of dollars.....
all because some scumbag and lawyer who KNOW that he did it, and know the system inside and out, work things such that he might get away with it.

If you did the crime, you should do the max time as anyone who was caught redhanded.
Not these crazy cases that the whackjob ends up geting 1/8th the time someone else did for the SAME crime, because he and his lawyer managed to make it SO hard for the cops and the courts to prove and try him for it.


Go ahead and throw you're hat in the ring with all the rest of em!   :lmao:  Who knows sirlamre.....you just might make it!!




Justice for Mark.....Imprison Employers Who Hire ILLEGALS!
sirlamre
Pioneer100© Member
 
Official Forum Troublemaker
Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 5196
MyResume: 
MyJob: Cisco VOIP and network security engineer
MyForum: Political Forum, Religion Forum
MyLove: My wife and Joshua and Daniel!
MyWish: 
MyFile: 
MyIntro: 
MySex: 2 kids - at least twice!
Status:  Offline
MyPOTD: 
Return to topBottom of page
 Posted: 11:39 pm

Quote
Reply
PM
Alert
voters: 0      
Though as a Baha'i, we're not allowed to run for public office or become a Party member.

Defeats the concepts of unity -- since by definition, we're not united with "them folks over there" any more.
That's why my posts in here (try anyway) to not be partisan oriented...

I try to be an equal opportunity basher..::sgrin::
foxglovepress
Forum-Blogger©
Original500© Member

NON-PC!!
Joined: 
Location: USA
Posts: 7764
MyResume: 
MyJob: Love my FAMILY, COUNTRY and Dogs!!
MyForum: Politics- Religion- Open Tal
MyLove: Family and ?
MyWish: A government for WE THE PEOPLE!
MyFile: [Download]
MyIntro: [Download]
MySex: On Hold for now.....
Status:  Offline
MyPOTD: 
Return to topBottom of page
 Posted: 11:51 pm

Quote
Reply
PM
Alert
voters: 0      
"I try to be an equal opportunity basher..::sgrin::"


 

And you do yourself proud sirlamre!  :lmao:




Justice for Mark.....Imprison Employers Who Hire ILLEGALS!
berinwitness
Original500© Member
 

Joined: 
Location: USA
Posts: 1280
MyResume: 
MyJob: 
MyForum: 
MyLove: Baha'u'llah, the Glory of God
MyWish: 
MyFile: 
MyIntro: 
MySex: celibate
Status:  Offline
MyPOTD: 
Return to topBottom of page
 Posted: 01:05 am

Quote
Reply
PM
Alert
voters: 0      
Right now I'm the only person who has voted "yes". But then I've always had the minority opinion.

I don't think it should be, by itself, grounds for conviction or even trial. Corroborating evidence should be conclusive. But truth-serum interrogations will cut down on the amount of lying.

As for the earlier remark about constitutional nightmares, I think we should get more serious about eliminating crime. At this point our society is too willing to let criminal activity go on.
Lady Cop
Pioneer100© Member


Joined: 
Location: Cape Cod
Posts: 9846
MyResume: [Download]
MyJob:  deputy sheriff (retired)
MyForum: LC's crimes and trials
MyLove: my family
MyWish: 
MyFile: [Download]
MyIntro: [Download]
MySex: straight woman
Status:  Offline
MyPOTD: 
Return to topBottom of page
 Posted: 01:11 am

Quote
Reply
PM
Alert
voters: 0      
hi Berin ... i'm the one who commented on constitutionality. and i'd say i'm pretty serious about crime. :)
UsedToRide
Original500© Member

^^^That is LOVE!!^^^
Joined: 
Location: My Own Private Hell
Posts: 6812
MyResume: [Download]
MyJob: Being evil
MyForum: UsedToRide's Bikers
MyLove: Bullet
MyWish: Bullet's freedom
MyFile: [Download]
MyIntro: 
MySex: Too damn long without any
Status:  Offline
MyPOTD: 
Return to topBottom of page
 Posted: 01:12 am

Quote
Reply
PM
Alert
voters: 0         
berinwitness wrote: But truth-serum interrogations will cut down on the amount of lying.


Except possibly for mentally handicapped people.

Or possibly people with a history of drug abuse.

Or some unknown allergic reaction.

Or sodium pentothal making someone crazy.

Or any one of any other hundred possible scenarios that we don't know could happen.  Till we have a whole shit-load of human guinea pigs, that is.

Aside from all those possibilities, consider the cost.  Medical, mental, drug use history, etc., etc.  Frankly, IMO, anyone who is "for" this idea is a whackjob.




Respect some, trust one, fear none
~~Bullet

A hundred criminals may be set free, but one innocent man should not go to prison, for that will make the entire system criminal
~Chief Justice T.L.Venkatraman
berinwitness
Original500© Member
 

Joined: 
Location: USA
Posts: 1280
MyResume: 
MyJob: 
MyForum: 
MyLove: Baha'u'llah, the Glory of God
MyWish: 
MyFile: 
MyIntro: 
MySex: celibate
Status:  Offline
MyPOTD: 
Return to topBottom of page
 Posted: 01:19 am

Quote
Reply
PM
Alert
voters: 0      
Lady Cop wrote: hi Berin ... i'm the one who commented on constitutionality. and i'd say i'm pretty serious about crime. :)
Okay, if your rating is "pretty serious" then mine must be somewhere around "psychopath". ::sgrin::
berinwitness
Original500© Member
 

Joined: 
Location: USA
Posts: 1280
MyResume: 
MyJob: 
MyForum: 
MyLove: Baha'u'llah, the Glory of God
MyWish: 
MyFile: 
MyIntro: 
MySex: celibate
Status:  Offline
MyPOTD: 
Return to topBottom of page
 Posted: 01:22 am

Quote
Reply
PM
Alert
voters: 0      
UsedToRide wrote: sodium pentothal making someone crazy

Good point - considering it happened to ME once. I wasn't yet six years old, but I could lift an adult off the floor. Imagine a career criminal have a proportional amount of ability.

Ads appear if not logged in.

Lady Cop
Pioneer100© Member


Joined: 
Location: Cape Cod
Posts: 9846
MyResume: [Download]
MyJob:  deputy sheriff (retired)
MyForum: LC's crimes and trials
MyLove: my family
MyWish: 
MyFile: [Download]
MyIntro: [Download]
MySex: straight woman
Status:  Offline
MyPOTD: 
Return to topBottom of page
 Posted: 01:23 am

Quote
Reply
PM
Alert
voters: 0      
even if it were feasible, the courts would be a logjam of motions to suppress the 'evidence' for a thousand different reasons. nobody would ever get convicted!






 Current time is 10:43 pm		Page:    1  2  Next Page Last Page  
24HourForums.com > The Top 10 Supported Forums > LC's Crimes & Trials > Would you support court-ordered drug "interrogations" of suspects?


Site Supporters
Posts Of The Day Mock Forums WowClassic



Themes and most mods done in collaboration with: WowClassic - powerful forum software with the best support service.
We are partners with Forum Owner Services
Powered by WowBB 1.7 - Copyright © 2003-2006 Aycan Gulez